Carnival Cruise Line passengers have raised concerns about the durability of their Sail & Sign cards, with some reporting that the printed designs and personal details are wearing away within days of boarding.
The complaints have prompted a response from Carnival Brand Ambassador John Heald, who has said he will investigate the issue with the ships after learning of the reports.
The discussion began when Facebook page The Cruise Chronicles shared photographs of a Diamond-level Sail & Sign card that had lost much of its shiny finish and ink print.
The page questioned whether Carnival needed to reconsider the design or materials used for the new cards, particularly as many frequent cruisers collect them as souvenirs.
While the cards serve practical purposes during a cruise, including opening cabin doors and making onboard purchases, they also hold sentimental value for passengers who keep them as reminders of their holidays.
Passengers Report Similar Problems Across Multiple Ships
The original post attracted numerous responses from passengers reporting similar experiences, suggesting the issue may extend beyond a single faulty card.
One guest said they had experienced fading on four cruises with the new design, with the printing beginning to rub away by the third day each time.
Another passenger, who had recently completed a two-week sailing aboard Carnival Venezia, reported that the shiny Diamond lettering had worn off both their card and their partner’s before the voyage ended, although the black printed information remained intact.
Other passengers mentioned similar problems aboard Carnival Horizon, Carnival Miracle, Carnival Panorama and Carnival Liberty.
Some reported needing replacements multiple times during a single sailing. One passenger claimed to have had their card reprinted three times during a ten-day cruise, while another said their card began peeling on the first day.
The complaints were not limited to Diamond members, either.
Several commenters reported similar deterioration on Gold, Platinum and Red cards, while others said their special Milestone cards had also lost their decorative finishes.
For passengers celebrating significant cruising milestones, the damage was particularly disappointing because these cards are often kept as commemorative items.
The discussion also raised questions about what might be causing the deterioration.
Several passengers suggested that sunscreen, particularly spray sunscreen, could be responsible for removing the printed finish. Others mentioned exposure to water, lotions or repeated use in casino machines.
However, some disputed the sunscreen explanation, saying their cards had deteriorated despite never coming into contact with such products.
One passenger reported that simply removing their card from a protective lanyard sleeve caused the printing to rub away, while another said their card had faded despite spending most of the cruise in a pocket.
Not everybody had experienced problems. Several passengers said their cards remained in excellent condition throughout their holidays, including on longer sailings.
The mixed reports leave it unclear whether the issue relates to particular card batches, materials, environmental factors or a combination of causes.
John Heald Promises To Investigate
Carnival Brand Ambassador John Heald responded directly to The Cruise Chronicles’ Facebook post, saying the issue had not previously been brought to his attention.
Heald suggested the original complaint might involve an isolated faulty card, but said he would make enquiries aboard the ships.
Following his response, The Cruise Chronicles pointed out that numerous passengers had reported experiencing the same problem.
Some commenters also said they had already raised the issue with crew members or requested replacement cards on previous voyages.
For now, passengers experiencing fading or damage can visit Guest Services to request a new card, as advised by Heald.
Several experienced cruisers also suggested requesting a fresh card towards the end of a sailing, particularly for those wanting an undamaged souvenir to take home.
Although the issue may appear minor compared with more significant cruise disruptions, the discussion highlights how important Sail & Sign cards remain to some of Carnival’s most loyal passengers.
With Heald now promising to check with the ships, it remains to be seen whether Carnival will identify a wider problem with the cards or make any changes to their production.
NEW DEALS JUST RELEASED!
See the latest Carnival cruise offers…
